Empowering Prisoners Through User Voice: Reflections from an SPS Internship

My internship with the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) was unusual in one key respect: I entered the organisation not only as an academic but also as someone who had served a lengthy prison sentence. I am also a co-founder of the Scottish Prisoner Advocacy and Research Collective (SPARC), which meant this work sat at the intersection of lived experience, research, and advocacy rather than as a detached exercise in organisational review with a token trainee academic looking for a break in writing their PhD (which I also was).

The internship gave me access to prisons across the estate, including establishments where I had previously been held. I spoke with prisoners, prison officers, education staff, and senior managers. The core task was to review the Scottish Prisoner Survey and assess whether it remains fit for purpose in a prison system that has changed significantly in recent years. However, what emerged was a broader set of questions about trust, participation, and how seriously the system takes the voices of people who live inside it.

Why User Voice Matters

User voice is often referenced in criminal justice policy but rarely embedded meaningfully. For prisoners, this gap is felt intensely. Across the prisons I visited, many people were sceptical about the Scottish Prisoner Survey, and rightly so, as it was challenging to draw out recent examples of how it had benefited them. The most common response was not hostility but resignation. People did not believe that completing the survey led to change. Some questioned whether anyone read the forms they filled in at all.

This scepticism matters. A survey that is not trusted will never produce meaningful data, no matter how technically well-designed it is. More importantly, it reinforces a broader sense that prisoners are objects of policy rather than participants in shaping it. If people feel their experiences are extracted and then ignored, disengagement is a rational response – something that will matter as the SPS move towards conducting these surveys digitally. You can give people all the access in the world but if they don’t value the exercise they won’t take part.

User voice is not about consultation as a gesture. It is about shifting power just enough to give people a sense of ownership of the process. When prisoners believe their input is taken seriously, participation and data quality should improve, and, fragile as it is in custodial settings, trust can begin to develop.

What the Internship Revealed About the Survey

The Scottish Prisoner Survey remains an essential tool. Prisoners and staff alike recognised its potential value. However, several recurring issues emerged:

  • Trust: Many prisoners doubt that the survey leads to tangible improvements.
  • Accessibility: The format and language do not work well for everyone, particularly people with literacy difficulties, neurodiversity, or limited engagement with formal paperwork.
  • Engagement: The survey often feels disconnected from everyday prison life and from the services people actually interact with.
  • Feedback loops: Prisoners rarely see what changes (if any) follow from survey findings.
  • These are not technical flaws alone; they are relational ones. They speak to how knowledge is gathered, who controls it, and who benefits from it.

Learning from Collaborative Models

One of the most compelling examples I encountered during this period was the Inside Out project at HMP & YOI Polmont. The project brought together care-experienced boys and young men with people from outside the prison in a structured, supportive space for dialogue, teamwork, and pro-social activity.

What made Inside Out work was not novelty, but collaboration. It treated participants as contributors rather than problems to be managed. It created conditions in which trust could develop because people could see that their presence and perspectives mattered.

There are clear lessons here for the Scottish Prisoner Survey. Co-production does not mean handing everything over, but it does mean involving prisoners meaningfully in shaping questions, methods, and interpretation. Without that, the survey risks remaining an extractive exercise rather than a tool for improvement.

Building Trust Through Education and External Partnership

Both prisoners and staff repeatedly identified education departments as spaces where trust is often stronger than elsewhere in the prison. Education staff tend to work alongside prisoners rather than over them, and they have direct insight into the barriers people face when engaging with formal processes.

One practical recommendation from the internship was to involve education and the prison staff who work there regularly more directly in the survey process, both to encourage participation and to shape delivery. This is not about shifting responsibility, but about grounding the survey in relationships that already function relatively well.

Alongside this, SPS has recognised the importance of working with external partners, particularly in the context of long-term budget constraints. Following my recommendations, SPS has engaged with the Scottish Centre for Criminal Justice Research (SCCJR) and explored collaboration with Fife College, which currently holds the national prison education contract. These partnerships bring methodological expertise, independence, and credibility, qualities that can help rebuild confidence in the survey process.

Lived Experience Inside Institutions

The fact that SPS offered this internship at all matters. It signals, at least in part, a willingness to take lived experience seriously rather than merely symbolically. My involvement did not end with the survey review; I was also invited to wider discussions on corporate planning and, subsequently, to a short-term working group on the future of the Scottish Prisoner Survey.

That progression is important. It suggests that lived experience is most valuable not when confined to “consultation” but when embedded in ongoing decision-making. This should not be exceptional. Universities, government departments, and local authorities routinely make decisions about people affected by punishment while excluding them from the room. SPS has (hopefully) began to recognise that another approach is possible.

What This Means Beyond the Survey

The implications of this work extend beyond a single survey or internship. They speak to how criminal justice institutions are coming to understand expertise. People with lived experience are often treated as subjects to be studied or managed rather than as contributors with knowledge shaped by survival, adaptation, and insight into system failure.

If Scotland is serious about rehabilitation, reintegration, and a public health approach to justice, then ‘user voice’ cannot remain optional or cosmetic. It must be designed into systems from the outset, properly supported, and linked to visible change. Otherwise, participation becomes another hollow ritual in a system people already distrust.

Concluding Reflections

This internship reinforced something that SPARC’s advocacy has long shown: when people are excluded from shaping the systems that govern them, harm multiplies. When they are included in a genuine way, outcomes improve and not because people suddenly become compliant, but because they are treated as human beings with insight into their own lives.

Reworking the Scottish Prisoner Survey through collaboration, co-production, and trust-building will not fix the prison system. But it is a meaningful step towards transparency, accountability, and responsiveness. More importantly, it sets a precedent: lived experience is not a risk to good governance – it is essential to it.

If this approach were extended across criminal justice policy, education, housing, and health, Scotland would be much closer to a system that reduces harm rather than reproducing it. That is the real opportunity this work points to.

reference

Inside out website – https://www.staf.scot/listing/category/inside-out

More from SPARC

Person writing in a notebook with a red pen
News, Prison Reform

Share this article: